Inter-Bureaucratic Civil-Military Relations
The Case of Planning Post-Peace Military Redeployment in Israel
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.64166/kajgbf27Abstract
The redeployment of the Israeli Defense Forces in the Negev region was one of the major domestic outcomes of the 1978 peace agreement between Israel and Egypt. There, the military and civilian bureaucracies were faced with the challenge of redeploying the army in a way which would minimize damage to civilian objectives in the area, on the one hand, and yield maximum benefits, on the other. Their failure to adequately meet this challenge can be attributed to the nature of civil-military relations in Israel at the bureaucratic level. These relations do not conform to the pattern of the "nation-in-arms" commonly attributed to Israel in the literature. Their parameters, namely the nature of the boundaries between the civilian and military and the relative institutional strengths of these establishments, suggest that an alternative model may be more useful in answering the question: why did very little development occur in the civilian sector while most of the objectives of the military redeployment were met?
References
Akzin, Benjamin, and Yehezkel Dror. 1965. Israel: High Pressure Planning. Syracuse: University of Syracuse Press.
Ben-Dor, Gabriel. 1973. “The military in the politics of innovation and integration.” Asian and African Studies 9(3):339-369.
------------- 1977. “Politics and army in Israel in the 197015.2) In Moshe Lissak and Imanuel Gutman (eds.), The Israeli Political System. Tel-Aviv: Am Oved (in Hebrew).
Bilski, Raphaella, I. Galnoor, D. Inbar, Y. Manor, and G. Sheffer. 1980. Can Planning Replace Politics? The Israeli Experience. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers.
Finer, Samuel Edward. 1962. The Man on Horseback: The Role of the Military in Politics. New York: Praeger.
Glick, Edward Bernard. 1967. Peaceful Conflict: The Non-Military Use of the Military. Harrisburg, Pa.: Stockpole Books.
Gradus, Yehuda, and Eliahu Stern. 1980. “Changing strategies of development: toward a regiopolis in the Negev Desert.” Journal of American Planning Association 46(4):410-23.
Halperin, Benjamin. 1962. “The role of the military in Israel.” Pp. 317-357, in J.J. Johnson (ed.), The Role of the Military in Underdeveloped Countries. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Horowitz, Dan. 1977. “Is Israel a Garrison State.” Jerusalem Quarterly 4 (Summer): 5875־.
Hurewitz, Jacob Coleman. 1974. Middle East Politics: The Military Dimension. New York: Octagon.
Janowitz, Morris. 1964. The Military in the Political Development of New Nations. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Luckham, A.R. 1971. “A comparative typology of civil-military relations.” Government and Opposition 6:5-35.
Ministry of Defense, Planning Division. 1979. IDF Deployment-Infrastructure Needs. Tel-Aviv: Ministry of Defense.
Perlmutter, Amos. 1969. Military and Politics in Israel: Nation Building and Role Expansion. London: Frank Cass.
----------------- 1978. Politics and the Military in Israel 1976-1977. London: Frank Cass and Company.
Rapaport, David. 1963. “A comparative theory of military and political types.” Pp. 71-101 in Samuel p. Huntington (ed.). Changing Patterns of Military Politics. New York: The Free Press of Gencoe.
Shachar, Sraia. 1977. Report of the Council for the Preparation of a Masterplan for the Development of the Negev. Beer-Sheva: Ben-Gurion University of the Negev and the Southern District Office of the Ministry of Interior.
State Comptroller. 1980. “The Development and Activities of the Civilian Ministries in Planning Civilian and Defense Deployment: Infrastructure and Construction in the Negev.” Annual Report No. 30. Jerusalem: Government Printing Office.
State Comptroller. 1981. “The Development and Activities of the Civilian Ministries in Planning Civilian and Defense Deployment: Infrastructure and Construction in the Negev.” Annual Report No. 31. Jerusalem: Government Printing Office.
Tahal, Team for Integrated Planning. 1979. A Plan to Develop the Negev - Deployment and Infrastructure. Report No. 1. Tel-Aviv: Tahal.
----------- 1980. A Plan to Develop the Negev - Deplopment and Infrastructure. Report No. 2. Tel-Aviv: Tahal.
U.S. Arms Control and Disarmament Agency. 1978. World Military Expenditures and Arms Transfers 1967-1976. Washington, D.C.: USACDA.
-------------- 1980. World Military Expenditures and Arms Transfers 1969-1978. Washington, D.C.: USACDA.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

